LONG BEFORE MILLIONS FELL IN LOVE WITH JOHNNY MATHIS’ VOICE, TWO TEENAGE BOYS IN SAN FRANCISCO WERE DREAMING ABOUT THE DAY SOMEONE MIGHT GIVE THEM A RECORDING CONTRACT. One was Johnny Mathis. The other was pianist Merl Saunders. Johnny later remembered performing with Merl from around the age of thirteen. They were young, ambitious, and surrounded by the music they loved. Between performances, they imagined which of them might become a recording artist first. At the time, it seemed almost impossible. Then, in 1956, Johnny traveled to New York to begin recording for Columbia Records. The dream they had once shared was becoming real. Saunders would build his own remarkable career, eventually collaborating with Jerry Garcia. Years later, Johnny still remembered those early days with affection. Before fame, there had been friendship, music, and two boys believing in the future.

Johnny Mathis' Early Life and Career Challenges

Introduction:

Long before Johnny Mathis became one of America’s most beloved voices, he and pianist Merl Saunders were two young musicians wondering whether their dreams would ever come true.

Before sold-out concerts, hit records, and a voice recognized around the world, Johnny Mathis was simply a young man in San Francisco with a passion for music — and a friend who shared his ambitions.

That friend was pianist Merl Saunders. The two began performing together when Mathis was around 13 years old. Saunders played piano while Mathis sang, and their early musical partnership gave both teenagers a chance to explore the music they loved while imagining what the future might hold.

Columbia Records (@ColumbiaRecords) on X

In a later interview, Mathis recalled how they used to wonder which of them would receive a recording contract first. At the time, the idea seemed more like a fantasy than a realistic possibility. They were young performers building their experience one appearance at a time, with no guarantee that the music would ever lead to a professional career.

Yet those memories remained meaningful to Mathis long after his life had changed. Looking back, he described that period with warmth, remembering the excitement of performing with Saunders and the innocent confidence they shared as aspiring musicians.

For Mathis, the opportunity that would transform his future arrived after Columbia Records executive George Avakian heard him perform in San Francisco. Impressed by the young singer’s voice, Avakian offered him a recording contract in 1955. The following year, Mathis traveled to New York City to begin recording his first album, Johnny Mathis: A New Sound in Popular Song.

The journey was a major turning point. Mathis had left the familiar surroundings of San Francisco and the musicians he had known for years to enter the professional recording world. His first album leaned toward jazz, reflecting the musical environment that had shaped him. Although it did not immediately become a commercial success, it marked the beginning of a recording career that would eventually span decades.

Merl Saunders & Jerry Garcia | iHeart

Saunders followed a different musical path, developing a respected career as a keyboardist and composer. He became particularly well known for his collaborations with guitarist Jerry Garcia, performing and recording with him in projects that brought together jazz, rock, blues, and improvisational music. His contributions became an important part of the San Francisco music scene.

Their careers took them in different directions, but the connection between the two musicians began long before either had achieved widespread recognition. One became famous for his romantic ballads; the other earned admiration for his adventurous keyboard playing and musical collaborations.

Perhaps the most touching part of their story is how ordinary it began. There were no guarantees, no headlines, and no certainty that either young musician would make a living from music. There were simply two teenagers, a piano, a voice, and a shared question about who might make it first.

Years later, Johnny Mathis could look back and recognize that the dream they once imagined had become reality. And before the world knew his name, there was Merl Saunders — a fellow musician who had been there when it all was still just beginning.

Video:

You Missed