JOHNNY MATHIS RECORDED A SONG HE COULDN’T BEAR TO HEAR AGAIN — AND YEARS LATER, HE STILL WONDERED HOW BURT BACHARACH HAD LET HIM SING IT THAT WAY. In the 1950s, Johnny was still discovering the voice that would eventually make him famous around the world. One of his early recordings was “Warm and Tender,” a song by the legendary Burt Bacharach. But Johnny wasn’t pleased with the result. He later remembered struggling to follow Bacharach’s musical direction and feeling that his performance sounded nothing like the romantic singer he wanted to become. The irony? That recording appeared on the reverse side of “It’s Not for Me to Say,” one of his breakthrough hits. The single sold a million copies. Decades later, Johnny could laugh about the experience, recalling how badly he thought he had sung. Even legends have recordings they wish they could redo.

Introduction:

Even the most celebrated singers have performances they wish they could erase. For Johnny Mathis, one early recording became a lasting reminder that finding the right voice is not always as effortless as it sounds.

Long before Johnny Mathis became one of the most recognizable romantic voices in popular music, he was still learning how to define his own musical identity. His smooth delivery and effortless-sounding vocals would eventually captivate millions, but not every early recording reflected the artist he hoped to become. One song in particular, “Warm and Tender,” remained a source of amusement—and embarrassment—for him decades later.

Written by Burt Bacharach and lyricist Hal David, “Warm and Tender” was among the early songs Mathis selected when beginning his recording career with Columbia Records. At the time, Bacharach was still establishing himself as a songwriter, long before becoming one of the most influential composers in popular music.

Mathis later recalled that working with Bacharach was not easy. Known for having a precise musical vision, Bacharach wanted performers to follow his interpretation closely. Mathis, however, struggled to respond to the direction he was given. He felt that the resulting performance sounded unlike the romantic vocal style he was trying to develop.

In a later interview, Mathis humorously described the recording as sounding more like Frankie Laine than the singer he wanted to be. Looking back, he could hardly believe that the performance had made it onto a commercial release. His reaction was both self-critical and affectionate, showing that even an artist with an extraordinary career can look back at an early recording and wonder what happened in the studio.

The irony was that “Warm and Tender” was released on the flip side of “It’s Not for Me to Say,” the 1957 single that became one of Mathis’s breakthrough successes. The A-side climbed to No. 5 on the Billboard pop chart, helping establish him as a major new voice in American popular music. Mathis later recalled that the record sold a million copies.

For listeners at the time, the two songs were simply different sides of the same record. For Mathis, however, they represented two very different feelings about his own performance. While “It’s Not for Me to Say” helped define his emerging reputation, “Warm and Tender” became the recording he struggled to appreciate.

There is something refreshingly human about this story. Mathis did not need to dismiss the song or blame anyone for the result. Instead, he could laugh at his younger self and acknowledge that he had not yet mastered the sound he wanted to create.

Looking back, the experience also highlights an important part of an artist’s development: discovering a personal style takes experimentation, mistakes and sometimes a willingness to hear what does not work.

Johnny Mathis would go on to build a remarkable career, recording countless romantic standards and earning a place among popular music’s most enduring voices. Yet the story of “Warm and Tender” remains a charming reminder that behind every polished performance may be an early attempt its creator would rather not replay.

Video: