BY 1990, JOHNNY MATHIS HAD SPENT DECADES SINGING THE WORLD’S MOST BEAUTIFUL LOVE SONGS. BUT DEEP INSIDE, HIS HEART STILL BELONGED TO THE JAZZ HE HAD LOVED AS A YOUNG MAN. That year, Johnny recorded *In a Sentimental Mood: Mathis Sings Ellington*, a tribute to the extraordinary music of Duke Ellington. It wasn’t the obvious commercial choice. Record companies often worried that jazz attracted smaller audiences than mainstream pop. But Johnny believed these melodies deserved to be heard. With elegant orchestral arrangements, he revisited classics including “Solitude,” “Prelude to a Kiss,” and “In a Sentimental Mood.” The result was deeply personal. In 1992, the album earned a Grammy nomination for Best Traditional Pop Performance. After more than three decades in the spotlight, Johnny had found another way to honor his musical beginnings.

In a Sentimental Mood: Mathis Sings Ellington (1990) | Johnny Mathis

Introduction:

After decades of becoming one of popular music’s most beloved romantic voices, Johnny Mathis returned to a musical passion that had inspired him long before fame: jazz.

By 1990, Johnny Mathis had become synonymous with some of the most enduring love songs in American popular music. His unmistakable voice had carried “Chances Are,” “Misty,” and countless other romantic favorites across generations. Yet behind that celebrated image was an artist whose musical interests reached far beyond the world of pop ballads.

One of his deepest inspirations was Duke Ellington.

For Mathis, Ellington was more than a legendary bandleader and composer. He was an American musical hero whose melodies possessed a sophistication and emotional depth that had fascinated the singer since his younger years. Mathis had long admired the way Ellington could move between intimate ballads, sophisticated harmonies, and lively orchestral arrangements.

That admiration eventually inspired In a Sentimental Mood: Mathis Sings Ellington, released by Columbia Records in 1990.

Seven things to know about Johnny Mathis, master of the romantic ballad

The project was not an obvious commercial choice. Mathis was already an established star, and a jazz-oriented tribute represented a departure from the familiar romantic repertoire that had made him famous. In an interview with the Los Angeles Times, he recalled that record companies tended to worry when the word “jazz” entered a conversation because the genre was perceived as having a smaller audience than mainstream pop.

Rather than abandon the idea, Mathis found another way to present it. He described the material as classic American songs written by an American composer. His determination reflected a simple belief: Ellington’s music deserved to be heard by audiences who might not ordinarily seek out jazz.

The resulting album brought together 18 selections associated with Ellington, including “Solitude,” “Prelude to a Kiss,” “In a Sentimental Mood,” “Satin Doll,” and “Don’t Get Around Much Anymore.” Its arrangements combined lush orchestral textures with the sound of a traditional big band, allowing Mathis to explore the melodies through his own distinctive vocal style.

Victoria's Secrets: Wonderful, Wonderful – That is Johnny Mathis – QNS

The recording was also a demanding artistic undertaking. In a later interview, Mathis described it as one of his favorite albums to make, but admitted that recording Ellington’s music placed considerable pressure on him. He wanted to do justice to a composer he had admired for so long.

That commitment did not go unnoticed. At the 34th Annual Grammy Awards in 1992, the album received a nomination for Best Traditional Pop Performance. It was recognition of a project that had followed artistic conviction rather than simply repeating a proven formula.

More than three decades into his career, Mathis had demonstrated that his musical identity could not be confined to romantic ballads. His tribute to Ellington offered listeners another side of the singer: an artist deeply connected to jazz, willing to revisit the music that had shaped his earliest ambitions.

For Johnny Mathis, In a Sentimental Mood was more than a tribute album. It was a return to an enduring musical love — and a reminder that even the most familiar voices can still have new stories to tell.

Video:

You Missed