ONE OF JOHNNY MATHIS’ EARLIEST HITS ALMOST SLIPPED AWAY — UNTIL A SECOND SONG GAVE IT NEW LIFE. When Columbia released “Wonderful! Wonderful!” in November 1956, Johnny Mathis was still searching for his place in American music. The record didn’t become an overnight sensation. Weeks passed. Then months. Meanwhile, another beautiful ballad, “It’s Not for Me to Say,” was preparing to reach listeners through both records and the Hollywood film *Lizzie*. Something remarkable followed. As “It’s Not for Me to Say” gained popularity, audiences began discovering “Wonderful! Wonderful!” all over again. By July 1957, both songs were enjoying chart success. The young singer who had struggled to establish himself suddenly had two memorable recordings capturing America’s attention. Sometimes, a beautiful song simply needs the right moment to find its audience. Which Johnny Mathis classic touches your heart more — “Wonderful! Wonderful!” or “It’s Not for Me to Say”?
Introduction: Sometimes, a song does not become a success when it first reaches the public. Sometimes, it needs another song to open…