ONE SONG HELPED DEFINE JOHNNY MATHIS — AND MORE THAN SIX DECADES LATER, AMERICA STILL HASN’T FORGOTTEN IT. When Johnny Mathis recorded “Chances Are” in 1957, no one could have known how deeply the song would become woven into American musical memory. Its gentle melody and Johnny’s unmistakable delivery turned it into one of his signature recordings. Decades passed. Musical fashions changed again and again. Yet “Chances Are” endured. The recording eventually entered the Grammy Hall of Fame, and in 2024 it was selected for preservation in the Library of Congress’ National Recording Registry. That is the remarkable thing about Johnny Mathis: his greatest recordings didn’t merely survive their era. They became part of the soundtrack people carried through courtships, marriages, anniversaries, heartbreaks and memories spanning generations.
Introduction: Some songs belong to a particular moment in time. Others seem to escape it entirely. For Johnny Mathis, “Chances Are” became…